A gold IRA is legitimate — but the industry attracts bad actors. Here are the nine most common scams, the red flags, and how to vet any company.
After a decade reviewing this industry, I’ve seen the same playbooks repeat. None of this means gold IRAs are a scam — they’re a legitimate, IRS-sanctioned way to hold physical metals for retirement. It means you should know the warning signs before you wire a rollover.
Ads promise you can store IRA gold in a home safe through a “checkbook LLC.” The IRS has never blessed this, and it can disqualify your entire IRA, triggering taxes and penalties. IRA metals must sit with an approved custodian and depository (IRC §408(m)).
The biggest profit center for bad dealers is steering you from low-margin bullion into “rare,” “proof,” or “collectible” numismatic coins at huge markups. Many collectibles aren’t even IRA-eligible, and the premiums can take years to earn back.
You’re drawn in by an ad for low-premium bullion, then pressured on the phone into a different, far pricier product “because it’s a better deal right now.”
Doomsday scripts — imminent dollar collapse, “gold confiscation,” one-day-only pricing — are designed to rush you past due diligence. Legitimate firms let you take your time.
The real cost is often the spread between buy and sell price, not the advertised “fee.” A 30–40% spread can quietly erase years of gains. Always ask for the buy price, the current sell/buyback price, and the spread in writing.
“Get $10,000 in free silver” offers are typically baked into inflated prices elsewhere in the order. Nothing is free; check the all-in math.
Some schemes sell “unallocated” or “pooled” metal you never actually own in segregated form, with no independent audit. Insist on allocated, segregated storage at a named, insured depository.
Paid “reviews,” invented award badges, and implied celebrity backing are common. Cross-check ratings on independent platforms and read the actual complaints, not just the star score.
Arrangements where the dealer “leases” or holds your metal off the books, outside an IRS-approved depository, put your assets and your IRA status at risk.
This is exactly what our reviews do — and what you can repeat yourself:
Act quickly and report it — reporting also helps regulators build cases:
Ready to compare vetted companies? See our reviewed top five and the verified-review methodology behind the rankings.
Educational information, not financial, tax, or legal advice. Reviewed June 2026.
Verify the rules yourself and know where to turn. Official government and regulator sources:
On Gold Advisor: Vetted top 5 · Our methodology · Company quiz
See the full Gold IRA rules, regulators & resources hub for IRS publications, how to vet a company, and where to file a complaint.